Scouting report · NLY
David L. Finkelstein
Annaly's CEO since March 2020 and Co-CIO; a former New York Fed MBS strategist
- Born / age
- (53)
- Role
- Chief Executive Officer & Co-Chief Investment Officer; Director
- In the role
- 7 yr
- Education
- BA University of Washington
- Front Office rank
- not ranked yet
NLY
Annaly Capital Management, Inc.Mortgage REIT
- Title
- Chief Executive Officer & Co-Chief Investment Officer; Directorsrc
- In role
- since 2020-03 (7 yr)
Stake value$8.8m411,922 shares · as of 13 Apr 2026
—thin record
Scouting sheetas of 24 Sep 2026
Delivers guidance—no promises on the record yet
Answers the question—no call reviewed yet
Capital allocation60company five-year record: neutral
Pay design73book value, roe, tsr, margin, strategic, individual, time only · 93.2% for · 0.95% of net income
Skin in the game42stake worth $8.8m, 0.5× last year's pay
—Hit rate
—Pay at risk
93%Say-on-pay
—Airtime on calls
- Beat
- 0
- Met
- 0
- Missed
- 0
- Withdrawn
- 0
- Still open
- 0
- Answers on calls
- 0
- Questions dodged
- 0
- Dodges / 100 answers
- —
Personal and ownership data
What to weigh
Watch 5
- Sold 50,000 shares every quarter under 10b5-1 plans: four sales between 2025-11-03 and 2026-08-03, about $4.5m in total, and no purchases. The FY2025 10-K shows a plan adopted 2025-11-12 for up to 198,223 shares with a last window of Nov-Dec 2026src
- The Form 4 for the 2026-04-27 sale says the plan was adopted 2024-05-16. The FY2025 10-K puts the April 27-June 16, 2026 window under the 2025-11-12 plan. One of the two filings is wrongsrc
- Key-person concentration: he has held the CIO or Co-CIO title as well as CEO for most of his tenure, and is the company's public face and main link to the boardsrc
- His beneficially owned stake (411,922 shares, under 1%) was about $9.4m at the $22.89 price of his August 2026 sale. That is less than half his $19.3m 2025 Summary Compensation Table paysrc
- 2023 Summary Compensation Table pay was $15.3m in a year when GAAP net income was a $1.643bn loss. Much of that loss was mark-to-market, and the bonus pays on economic return, not GAAPsrc
In their favour 2
- The cash bonus scorecard pays on tangible economic return (change in book value plus dividends), relative and absolute, not on EAD alone. PSUs pay 0-150% but are capped at 100% if three-year TSR is negativesrc
- The Chair is independent, the proxy reports no related party transactions, hedging and pledging are banned, and he meets the 6x-salary ownership guidelinesrc
Pay
Salary and otherBonus, stock, options, incentive
The table
- Bonus pays on
- Cash incentive: 75% corporate scorecard (relative tangible economic return 40%, absolute tangible economic return 20%, operating efficiency 20%, available financing 20%) and 25% individual; max 150%. For 2025 the corporate part scored 139% and the individual multiplier was 150%; the $6.2m target paid $8.773m
- Long-term award pays on
- Equity awarded at target: 60% PSUs (three-year relative tangible economic return and average EAD ROE, 0-150%, capped at 100% if TSR is negative), 40% RSUs vesting ratably over three yearssrc
- Pay at risk not on file
- Pays on returns book value, roe, tsr, margin, strategic, individual, time only
- Shareholder vote 93.2% for
- Pay vs profit 0.95% of net income
CEO pay ratio 64 : 1
Career
- 2025 – nowAnnaly Capital Managementsrc
Chief Executive Officer & Co-Chief Investment Officer
Co-CIO title from January 2025 - 2022 – 2025Annaly Capital Managementsrc
Chief Executive Officer & Chief Investment Officer
Re-assumed CIO in November 2022 when Ilker Ertas left; the President title passed to COO Steven Campbell in December 2022 (8K-2022-12-15) - 2020 – 2022Annaly Capital Managementsrc
Chief Executive Officer & President; director
Appointed 2020-03-13 after an interim period under CFO Glenn Votek that followed Kevin Keyes' departure in November 2019 (8K-2019-11-21). Kept the CIO title until December 2021 - 2016 – 2020Annaly Capital Managementsrc
Chief Investment Officer
Employed by the external manager, Annaly Management Company LLC, until the internalization closed on 2020-06-30 (8K-2020-07-01) - 2015 – 2016
- 2013 – 2015
- 2009 – 2013Federal Reserve Bank of New Yorksrc
Officer, Markets Group; primary strategist and policy adviser for the MBS purchase program
Undated in the sources
- Salomon Smith Barney, Citigroup Inc. and Barclays PLCsrc, Agency MBS trading positions
Not located: The years at Salomon Smith Barney, Citigroup and Barclays before 2009 are not dated in any filing read (2019 and 2026 proxies, FY2025 10-K, 2020 appointment 8-K)
The promise ledger
No promise on the record yet: the research routine has not scored this company's guidance.
Background
- Family No family-relationship statement for him was found in the 2026 proxy, the FY2025 10-K or his 2020 appointment 8-K. The 2026 proxy reports no related party transactionssrc
- Service Officer in the New York Fed's Markets Group from 2009 to 2013, working on the MBS purchase programsrc
- Other Vice Chair of the Treasury Market Practices Group sponsored by the New York Fed, and a member of the Dallas Fed's Financial Sector Advisory Councilsrc
- Other His 2020 CEO employment agreement set a $1m salary and a guaranteed minimum 2020 bonus of $6.75m, for a total 2020 opportunity of $12.75msrc
- Boards The only non-independent director. The Chair and CEO roles have been split since November 2019, and Thomas Hamilton has been independent Chair since May 2025src
Sources14
- Filing Annaly Capital Management DEF 14A for the 2026 annual meeting (accession 0001104659-26-052954) · 2026-04-30
- Filing Annaly Capital Management 10-K for FY2025 (0001043219-26-000013): Information about our Executive Officers, Item 9B trading arrangements, signatures · 2026-02-12
- Filing Annaly 8-K Item 5.07, 2026 annual meeting results (0001043219-26-000034) · 2026-06-11
- Filing Annaly 8-K Item 5.02, Finkelstein appointed CEO and President, new employment agreement (0001193125-20-073747) · 2020-03-16
- Filing Annaly 8-K Item 5.02, departure of Kevin Keyes, Votek interim CEO, independent Chair appointed (0001193125-19-296991) · 2019-11-21
- Filing Annaly 8-K Items 1.01/5.02, closing of the management internalization on 2020-06-30 (0001193125-20-184568) · 2020-07-01
- Filing Annaly 8-K Item 5.02, CIO Ilker Ertas departs, Finkelstein re-assumes CIO (0001628280-22-030082) · 2022-11-16
- Filing Annaly 8-K Item 5.02, Steven Campbell named President (0001193125-22-305910) · 2022-12-15
- Filing Annaly Capital Management DEF 14A for the 2019 annual meeting (0001206774-19-001280), executive officer bios · 2019-04-09
- Filing SEC XBRL companyconcept us-gaap/NetIncomeLoss, CIK 1043219 (FY2025 10-K, 0001043219-26-000013) · 2026-02-12
- Filing Form 4, David L. Finkelstein (reporting CIK 1688537), sale of 2025-11-03 (0001688537-25-000003) · 2025-11-04
- Filing Form 4, David L. Finkelstein, sale of 2026-02-18 (0001688537-26-000005) · 2026-02-19
- Filing Form 4, David L. Finkelstein, sale of 2026-04-27 (0001688537-26-000009) · 2026-04-30
- Filing Form 4, David L. Finkelstein, sale of 2026-08-03 (0001688537-26-000011) · 2026-08-04