Scouting report · AIG

Keith Walsh

Ex-Citi insurance analyst and Marsh CFO; AIG CFO since November 2024

Born / age
(51)
Role
EVP & Chief Financial Officer
In the role
2 yr
Education
BS University at Albany, SUNY
Front Office rank
not ranked yet
AIG
American International Group, Inc.Insurance
Title
EVP & Chief Financial Officersrc
In role
since 2024-11 (2 yr)
Stake value$2.6m0.006% · 34,133 shares · as of 31 Jan 2026
—thin record

Scouting sheetas of 24 Sep 2026

Delivers guidance—0 beat · 1 met · 0 missed · 1 withdrawn — fewer than 4, not scored
Answers the question801 dodge in 5 answers on 2 calls
Capital allocation—company five-year record: neutral — inherited: the five-year record is mostly a predecessor's
Pay design6081% performance-conditioned · underwriting profit, eps, roe, book value, relative tsr, individual, time only · 77.5% for · 0.24% of net income
Skin in the game38stake worth $2.6m, 0.3× last year's pay
50%Hit rate
81%Pay at risk
78%Say-on-pay
20%Airtime on calls
Beat
0
Met
1
Missed
0
Withdrawn
1
Still open
0
Answers on calls
5
Questions dodged
1
Dodges / 100 answers
20.0

Personal and ownership data

Full name
Keith Walsh
Age
51src
Education
BS, University at Albany, SUNYsrc

Not on file yet: born, place of birth, citizenship, marital status.

Shares held
34,133 AIG, 2026-01-31src
Share of company
0.006%
Stake value
$2.6m
Stake ÷ pay
0.3× last year's pay
Traded, 12 months
bought $0, sold $0src
Last pay
$7.5m 2025src
Pay at risk
81%
Say-on-pay vote
77.5% forsrc
CEO pay ratio
346 : 1

What to weigh

Watch 5

  • On 2026-08-07 he told an analyst AIG had long since stopped reiterating its 15-20% financial-leverage target (dossier S8 row 9, withdrawn). Yet his own 2025 pay goals list keeping debt-to-capital within that rangesrc
  • On the 2026-08-07 call, asked about reserve adequacy in accident years 2021 and 2022, he answered about 2016 and 2023. The dossier logs it as a dodge on the same book as its prior-year-development flagsrc
  • AIG's FY2025 10-K lists his prior career as EVP and CFO of Marsh & McLennan Companies, 2012-2024. The appointment 8-K says he was CFO of the Marsh subsidiary from 2017 and head of IR for the parent from 2012 to 2017. The 10-K line overstates the rolesrc
  • The proxy disclosed a late Form 4 (filed 2026-02-02) covering five dividend reinvestments, 27.25 shares from Dec 2024 to Dec 2025, blamed on administrative error. Immaterial, but it is on the recordsrc
  • Small stake for a CFO: 34,133 shares beneficially owned (25,847 of them vesting within 60 days) at 2026-01-31, against $7.5m of 2025 pay. Executive officers must hold 3x salary. The proxy says all named executives complysrc

In their favour 1

  • In post through the whole 2025 promise window, and the continuity now that the CEO who set those targets has gone. He co-owns the $5-6bn 2025 buyback guide, met at $5.8bnsrc

Pay

Salary and otherBonus, stock, options, incentive

  • $5.5m2024
  • $7.5m2025
The table
YearSalaryBonusStockOptionsIncentiveOtherTotal
2024$200k$0$3.2m$0$2.1m$11k$5.5msrc
2025$1.0m$1.2m$2.0m$625k$2.6m$95k$7.5msrc
Bonus pays on
STI target $1.5m = target x Company Performance Score (133% for 2025) x individual score (130%), capped at 200%. The company score weights four metrics equally: calendar-year combined ratio, adjusted accident-year combined ratio, AATI per diluted share, core operating ROE. Paid $2.6m, 173% of target
Long-term award pays on
$2.5m target LTI: 50% PSUs over 2025-27 (relative calendar-year combined ratio, adjusted accident-year combined ratio, AATI/share growth, adjusted tangible book value per share growth, relative TSR), 25% options, 25% time-vested RSUssrc
  • Pay at risk 81% performance-conditioned
  • Pays on returns underwriting profit, eps, roe, book value, relative tsr, individual, time only
  • Shareholder vote 77.5% for
  • Pay vs profit 0.24% of net income

CEO pay ratio 346 : 1

Career

  1. 2024 – now
    American International Groupsrc
    EVP & Chief Financial Officer
    Joined 2024-10-21; CFO effective 2024-11-08 (8KA2-2024-11-08)
  2. 2017 – 2024
    Marsh (subsidiary of Marsh & McLennan Companies)src
    Chief Financial Officer of Marsh
  3. 2012 – 2017
    Marsh & McLennan Companiessrc
    Vice President & Head of Investor Relations
  4. 1998 – 2012
    Citisrc
    Equity research analyst covering the insurance sector
    The release gives 14 years at Citi before the 2012 move; the 1998 start is derived from that, not stated

Not located: Exact start year at Citi is derived (14 years before 2012), not stated; nothing located before Citi

The promise ledger2 scored · 0 open

ResultWhat was promisedWhere it is scoredHow
M MetFY2025 · $5–6bn of share repurchasesAIG row 5said it, with a colleague
W WithdrawnFinancial leverage target of 15–20%AIG row 9said it

Questions dodged20.0 per 100 answers

  1. Reserve adequacy by accident year. Call 2026-08-07 [11] · Meyer Shields asked specifically about accident years '22 and '21 — "Is there significant IBNR there that would also need to be reviewed?" After a preamble from the CEO on process [12], Walsh answered about '16 and '23 and about ranges of estimates [13]. The years asked about were not addressed. Logged as a note this quarter; if it recurs it bec…

    from AIG · dossier-2026-09-24.md

Calls reviewed

  • FY2026 Q1 call — 0 answers, 14% of the words
  • FY2026 Q2 call — 5 answers, 25% of the words

Background

  • Family The appointment 8-K states he has no family relationship with any AIG director or executive officer and no Item 404(a) related-party interestsrc
  • Other A Marsh McLennan hire: Zaffino, who appointed him, was CEO of Marsh, LLC from 2011 to 2017, while Walsh ran Marsh McLennan's investor relations from 2012 to 2017src
  • Other Letter agreement effective 2024-09-13 (with an amendment dated 2024-10-04) carries non-solicitation and non-disclosure covenantssrc

Sources14

  1. Filing AIG 8-K Item 5.02, Walsh appointed EVP & CFO (0000005272-24-000101) · 2024-09-18
  2. Filing AIG press release, 8-K Ex. 99.1 of 2024-09-18 (0000005272-24-000101) · 2024-09-18
  3. Filing AIG 8-K/A No. 1, CFO effective date moved to 2024-11-06 (0000005272-24-000112) · 2024-10-11
  4. Filing AIG 8-K/A, CFO appointment effective 2024-11-08 (0000005272-24-000130) · 2024-11-08
  5. Filing AIG 10-K FY2025, Item 10 'Our Executive Officers' (0000005272-26-000023) · 2026-02-12
  6. Filing AIG DEF 14A 2026 (0000005272-26-000039) · 2026-03-31
  7. Filing AIG 8-K Items 5.02/5.07, 2026 annual meeting results (0000005272-26-000066) · 2026-05-14
  8. Filing SEC XBRL companyconcept us-gaap/NetIncomeLoss, CIK 5272 (FY2025 10-K, 0000005272-26-000023) · 2026-02-12
  9. Filing Form 4, Keith Walsh (reporting CIK 2041533): late-reported dividend reinvestments and tax withholding (0002041533-26-000002) · 2026-02-02
  10. Filing Form 4, Keith Walsh, 2026 RSU and option grant of 2026-02-17 (0002041533-26-000004) · 2026-02-18
  11. Filing Form 4, Keith Walsh, shares withheld for tax 2026-03-03 (0002041533-26-000006) · 2026-03-03
  12. Filing EDGAR submissions index for AIG (CIK 5272): Form 4 filings 2025-09-01 to 2026-09-24; reporting CIK 2041533 filed only the three above · 2026-09-24
  13. Call transcript AIG Q2 2026 earnings call (2026-08-07), market data
  14. Web search result WebSearch: Insurance Journal 2024-09-20, 'People Moves: AIG Appoints Walsh CFO' (search summary repeats the press release: 14 years at Citi equity research covering insurance; BS University at Albany-SUNY; MBA NYU Stern) · 2026-09-24