Scouting report · FAF

Matthew F. Wajner

First American controller, CAO and treasurer since 2009; CFO since April 2025

Born / age
(50)
Role
Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
In the role
2 yr
Education
BA University of California, Los Angeles
Front Office rank
not ranked yet
FAF
First American Financial CorporationHousing volume
Title
Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officersrc
In role
since 2025-04 (2 yr)
Stake value—no holding or price on file
—thin record

Scouting sheetas of 24 Sep 2026

Delivers guidance—no promises on the record yet
Answers the question—no call reviewed yet
Capital allocation—company not reviewed yet
Pay design87margin, roe, relative tsr, strategic, time only · 97.5% for · 0.34% of net income
Skin in the game—no holding or price on file
—Hit rate
—Pay at risk
98%Say-on-pay
—Airtime on calls
Beat
0
Met
0
Missed
0
Withdrawn
0
Still open
0
Answers on calls
0
Questions dodged
0
Dodges / 100 answers
—

Personal and ownership data

Full name
Matthew F. Wajner
Age
50src
Education
BA Business Economics, University of California, Los Angelessrc

Not on file yet: born, place of birth, citizenship, marital status.

Shares held
30,079 FAF, 2026-03-16src
Share of company
0.03%
Traded, 12 months
bought $0, sold $0src
Last pay
$2.1m 2025src
Say-on-pay vote
97.5% forsrc
CEO pay ratio
101 : 1

What to weigh

Watch 2

  • First CFO role, promoted from treasurer in the unplanned April 2025 succession that moved the CFO to CEOsrc
  • The bonus pays on non-GAAP pretax margin and ROE that exclude investment and venture gains and losses, intangible amortization and, at the committee's discretion, other non-operating items; as CFO he reports the figures they are built fromsrc

In their favour 2

  • Meets the 3x-salary ownership guideline per the proxy, with hedging and pledging bannedsrc
  • No open-market sale in the last 12 months: his Form 4s show only grants and shares withheld for tax on vestingsrc

Pay

Salary and otherBonus, stock, options, incentive

  • $860k2024
  • $2.1m2025
The table
YearSalaryBonusStockOptionsIncentiveOtherTotal
2024$350k$0$297k$0$203k$11k$860ksrc
2025$543k$0$862k$0$710k$17k$2.1msrc
Bonus pays on
AIP 50% adjusted pretax margin, 50% adjusted ROE, 50-200% of target, committee discretion ±30 points; paid half cash, half Bonus RSUs vesting over 3 years; 2025 paid 142%
Long-term award pays on
LTI split 50% PRSUs on 3-year TSR relative to the S&P MidCap 400 (0-200%) and 50% time-vested RSUs (3 years); 2025 target LTI $625ksrc
  • Pay at risk not on file
  • Pays on returns margin, roe, relative tsr, strategic, time only
  • Shareholder vote 97.5% for
  • Pay vs profit 0.34% of net income

CEO pay ratio 101 : 1

Career

  1. 2025 – now
    First American Financial Corporationsrc
    Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
    Effective 2025-04-10
  2. 2020 – 2025
    First American Financial Corporationsrc
    Vice President, Treasurer
    From August 2020
  3. 2013 – 2020
    First American Financial Corporationsrc
    Vice President, Chief Accounting Officer
    Appointed 2013-03-27
  4. 2010 – 2013
    First American Financial Corporationsrc
    Controller
    From September 2010
  5. 2009 – 2010
    The First American Corporationsrc
    Director of SEC Reporting

Undated in the sources

  • JPMorgan Chase & Co. and PricewaterhouseCoopers LLPsrc, Divisional controller for banking operations; auditor in public accounting

Not located: Pre-2009 employers' years and titles are not stated in any filing read; the firm names rest on the company web bio only

The promise ledger

No promise on the record yet: the research routine has not scored this company's guidance.

Background

  • Family The 2026 proxy states there are no family relationships among directors, nominees and executive officers; the April 2025 8-K says the same for him and reports no Item 404(a) related-party transactionssrc
  • Other No outside board or trustee role was located in the filings read or in a web searchsrc
  • Other Employment agreement first signed on his 2025 promotion, renewed 2026 to run to 2028-12-31 with a $675k minimum salary; termination without cause pays twice salary plus the second-largest of the prior three bonusessrc

Sources10