Scouting report · ACGL

Nicolas Papadopoulo

Arch lifer since 2001; ran reinsurance, then insurance; CEO since Oct 2024

Born / age
(63)
Role
Chief Executive Officer and Class III Director
In the role
2 yr
Education
Graduate École Polytechnique (France)
Front Office rank
not ranked yet
ACGL
Arch Capital Group Ltd.Insurance
Title
Chief Executive Officer and Class III Directorsrc
In role
since 2024-10 (2 yr)
Stake value$157.6m0.47% · 1.7m shares · as of 9 Mar 2026
—thin record

Scouting sheetas of 24 Sep 2026

Delivers guidance—0 beat · 1 met · 0 missed · 0 withdrawn — fewer than 4, not scored
Answers the question980 dodges in 46 answers on 2 calls
Capital allocation—company five-year record: compounds — inherited: the five-year record is mostly a predecessor's
Pay design8077% performance-conditioned · roe, strategic, book value, relative tsr, time only · 94.1% for · 0.33% of net income
Skin in the game76stake worth $157.6m, 11× last year's pay
100%Hit rate
77%Pay at risk
94%Say-on-pay
43%Airtime on calls
Beat
0
Met
1
Missed
0
Withdrawn
0
Still open
0
Answers on calls
46
Questions dodged
0
Dodges / 100 answers
0.0

Personal and ownership data

Full name
Nicolas Papadopoulo
Age
63src
Education
Graduate, École Polytechnique (France)src

Not on file yet: born, place of birth, citizenship, marital status.

Shares held
1,659,915 ACGL, 2026-03-09src
Share of company
0.47%
Stake value
$157.6m
Stake ÷ pay
11× last year's pay
Traded, 12 months
bought $0, sold $2.1msrc
Last pay
$14.6m 2025src
Pay at risk
77%
Say-on-pay vote
94.1% forsrc
CEO pay ratio
105 : 1

What to weigh

Watch 5

  • 2024 reported pay was $31.8m, driven by a one-time 'Outperformance Award' on the leadership transition: $16.1m of premium-priced options (strike $161.24) plus $6.9m of time-vested restricted sharessrc
  • Say-on-pay fell to 84.7% at the 2025 meeting (93.9-95.3% in 2021-2024); the company attributes it to the one-time transition awards. It recovered to 94.1% in May 2026src
  • 2025 bonus paid at the 200% maximum (financial and strategic parts both at 200%) in a year when TSR ranked 10th percentile of peers; for 2026 his bonus target rose to 270% of salary from 200% and his LTI target to 785% from 560%src
  • Holds a personal $2.5m stake in Premia, an Arch-sponsored reinsurer that does business with Arch subsidiaries (disclosed, reviewed by disinterested directors)src
  • Thin say-vs-do record: only one of the seven S8 rows is his (the California wildfire loss estimate, met at the top of the range); the CFO makes nearly every checkable statementsrc

In their favour 2

  • Long in-house tenure across both reinsurance and insurance, and appointment through a planned succession rather than an outside searchsrc
  • Pay mix: 77% of 2025 target pay performance-based; hedging prohibited; CEO ownership guideline 6x salary, all NEOs in compliancesrc

Pay

Salary and otherBonus, stock, options, incentive

  • $7.1m2023
  • $31.8m2024
  • $14.6m2025
The table
YearSalaryBonusStockOptionsIncentiveOtherTotal
2023$850k$0$2.3m$734k$2.8m$442k$7.1msrc
2024$993k$0$9.6m$17.0m$3.7m$473k$31.8msrc
2025$1.3m$0$5.5m$1.8m$5.2m$786k$14.6msrc
Bonus pays on
Cash bonus: 70% group ROE against the formula-plan ROE scale (target 13.34% for 2025), 30% strategic goals; target 200% of salary, capped at 2x target; 2025 paid 200%
Long-term award pays on
55% performance shares on 3-year adjusted tangible book value per share growth (target 11%/yr, threshold 6%, max 16%) with a +/-25% relative TSR modifier; 25% options; 20% time-vested restricted shares; all vest over three yearssrc
  • Pay at risk 77% performance-conditioned
  • Pays on returns roe, strategic, book value, relative tsr, time only
  • Shareholder vote 94.1% for
  • Pay vs profit 0.33% of net income

CEO pay ratio 105 : 1

Career

  1. 2024-10 – now
    Arch Capital Groupsrc
    Chief Executive Officer and director
  2. 2021-01 – 2024-10
    Arch Capital Groupsrc
    President and Chief Underwriting Officer; CEO of Arch Worldwide Insurance Group
  3. 2017-09 – 2020-12
    Arch Capital Groupsrc
    Chairman and CEO of Arch Worldwide Insurance Group; Chief Underwriting Officer for Property and Casualty Operations
  4. 2014-07 – 2017-09
    Arch Capital Groupsrc
    Chairman and CEO of Arch Reinsurance Group
  5. 2001-12 – 2014-07
    Arch Reinsurance Ltd. (Bermuda)src
    A variety of underwriting roles

Undated in the sources

  • Sorema N.A. Reinsurance Group (U.S. subsidiary of Groupama)src, Various positions
  • French Ministry of Finance, Insurance Departmentsrc, Insurance examiner

Not located: Years before December 2001 (Sorema N.A. and the French Ministry of Finance) are named but undated in the 8-K and proxies read; the last ten years are fully sourced

The promise ledger1 scored · 0 open

ResultWhat was promisedWhere it is scoredHow
M MetQ1 2025 · California wildfires · net loss $450–550mACGL row 3said it

Questions dodged0.0 per 100 answers

None logged on the calls reviewed.

Calls reviewed

  • FY2026 Q1 call — 25 answers, 41% of the words
  • FY2026 Q2 call — 21 answers, 44% of the words

Background

  • Family The 8-K announcing his appointment states there are no family relationships between him and any other director or executive officersrc
  • Boards Sat on the board of COFACE SA (Arch is a shareholder) as an Arch nominee; stepped down in February 2025 to concentrate on his role at Arch and was replaced by another Arch executivesrc
  • Service Earlier in his career was an insurance examiner at the French Ministry of Finance's Insurance Departmentsrc
  • Investing Personally co-invested $2.5m for a 0.625% stake in Premia, the run-off reinsurer Arch and Kelso sponsored in 2017; Arch provides services and a quota-share treaty to it. Disclosed as a related-person transactionsrc
  • Other Employment agreement (2017, amended 2024-10-13): on termination without cause or for good reason, salary for the six-month notice period plus up to 24 months (less garden leave), 200% of target bonus, a pro-rated target bonus and up to 18 months of medical coversrc
  • Other Received Arch-investee board fees paid in euros ($43,081 for 2023, $26,923 for 2024), included in All Other Compensationsrc

Sources10