Scouting report · PUMP

Caleb L. Weatherl

Chief Financial Officer, PUMP since 2025-07src

Midland E&P co-founder and CEO/CFO; ProPetro CFO since July 2025

—thin record

Not ranked yet

Scouting sheet

as of 24 Sep 2026

Delivers guidance—no promises on the record yet

Answers the question—no call reviewed yet

Capital allocation—company not reviewed yet

Pay design67ebitda, fcf, strategic, individual, relative tsr, time only · 98.6% for · 187.72% of net income

Skin in the game3stake worth $20k, 0.0× last year's pay

Age: 39src
In the role: 1 yr
Promises scored: 0
Hit rate: —
Dodges / 100 answers: —
Airtime on calls: —

Every promise, oldest firstno scored promises yet

What to weigh

Watch 3

No prior public-company CFO role. The 8-K describes his experience as senior positions in private companiessrc
From 2026-10-30 he is also interim principal accounting officer, after the CAO resigned on 2026-09-16, with no replacement namedsrc
Small personal stake: 2,000 shares at the proxy record date and 27,338 after the August 2026 RSU settlement. The 3x-salary ownership guideline gives him five yearssrc

In their favour 1

Bought 2,000 shares on the open market at $4.91 on 2025-08-01, weeks after joiningsrc

Career

2025-07 – now
ProPetro Holding Corp.src
Chief Financial Officer
2023-05 – 2024-09
Garrison Energy (Midland, Texas E&P)src
Chief Executive Officer & Board Member
The press release says he co-founded it and secured a significant equity commitment to pursue upstream opportunities (PR-2025-07-14)
2017-12 – 2022-10
Stronghold Energy II Holdings (Midland, Texas E&P)src
President & CFO; board member from 2021-10
The press release says the company was sold in 2022 (PR-2025-07-14)
2016-06 – 2017-12
Desert Royalty Companysrc
Chief Financial Officer
2014-05 – 2016-06
Stronghold Energy Partnerssrc
Vice President, Co-Founder & Board Member
2013-08 – 2016-06
Weatherl Energy Investmentssrc
Vice President

Undated in the sources

Bain Capital; McKinsey & Companysrc, Earlier positions (undated in the filings)

Not located: 2022-10 to 2023-05 and 2024-09 to 2025-07 are not described in any filing. The Bain Capital and McKinsey years are not in a primary source; a people-search site carries dates and was not used

Achievements

Ran Stronghold Energy II as President & CFO for nearly five years, through COVID, until its sale in 2022src
Co-founded two Midland upstream companies (Stronghold Energy Partners in 2014, Garrison Energy in 2023) and was CEO of Garrisonsrc
Came in as the third person in ProPetro's principal-financial-officer seat in 2025, after CFO Schorlemer left on 2025-03-03 and CAO Davila filled insrc
2025 bonus paid 103.5% of his prorated target ($229,000)src

Education

Harvard College, AB Economicssrc
Harvard Business School, MBA Business Administrationsrc

Background

Family The appointment 8-K and the 2026-09-21 8-K both state there are no family relationships between him and any director or executive officer, and no Item 404(a) transactionssrc
Personal Says he grew up and built his career in Midland, where ProPetro is headquarteredsrc
Other Tier 2 participant in the executive severance plan; hire package of 100,482 RSUs and 100,482 PSUs, $525k salary, 90% target bonus, vehicle allowance and club duessrc

Pay

Salary and otherBonus, stock, options, incentive

2025$1.5m

The table

Year	Salary	Bonus	Stock	Options	Incentive	Other	Total
2025	$246k	$0	$1.0m	$0	$229k	$58k	$1.5m	src

Bonus pays on: Same executive bonus plan as the CEO at a 90% target: Adjusted EBITDA 40%, FCF excl. PROPWR capex 20%, PROPWR committed MW 10%, two safety metrics 20%, individual 10%; paid 103.5% of prorated target
Long-term award pays on: Hire grant of 100,482 RSUs and 100,482 PSUs; plan PSUs pay on three-year relative TSR, RSUs vest in thirdssrc

Pay at risk not on file
Pays on returns ebitda, fcf, strategic, individual, relative tsr, time only
Shareholder vote 98.6% for
Pay vs profit 187.72% of net income

What they own

$20k at the last price on file — 0× last year's pay
2,000 shares of PUMP · 0.0% of the companysrc
as of 2026-03-25
Last 12 months: bought $0, sold $0src

The promise ledger

No promise on the record yet: the research routine has not scored this company's guidance.

Sources

Filing ProPetro Holding Corp. DEF 14A (accession 0001104659-26-040891) · 2026-04-08
Filing ProPetro 8-K Item 5.02, Weatherl appointed CFO (0001680247-25-000112) · 2025-07-14
Filing ProPetro press release 'ProPetro Appoints Caleb Weatherl as Chief Financial Officer', Exhibit 99.1 to 0001680247-25-000112 · 2025-07-14
Filing ProPetro 8-K Item 5.02, CAO resignation; CFO to serve as interim principal accounting officer (0001680247-26-000110) · 2026-09-21
Filing ProPetro 8-K Item 5.02, departure of CFO David Schorlemer; Davila interim PFO (0001104659-25-020011) · 2025-03-04
Filing ProPetro 8-K Items 5.02/5.07, 2026 annual meeting results (0001104659-26-065695) · 2026-05-22
Filing SEC XBRL companyconcept us-gaap/NetIncomeLoss, CIK 1680247 (FY2025 10-K, 0001680247-26-000028) · 2026-02-19
Filing Form 4, Caleb Lyle Weatherl (reporting CIK 2078488), open-market purchase and hire RSU grant of 2025-08-01 (0001680247-25-000127) · 2025-08-04
Filing Form 4, Caleb Lyle Weatherl, RSU settlement and tax withholding of 2026-08-01 (0002078488-26-000002) · 2026-08-03
Filing EDGAR submissions index for reporting owner Weatherl Caleb Lyle (CIK 2078488): Form 3 2025-07-24; Form 4s 2025-08-04, 2026-03-03, 2026-08-03 · 2026-09-24