Scouting report · ALL

Thomas J. Wilson

Allstate CEO since January 2007, Chair since May 2008, President again since 2018

Born / age
(68)
Role
Chair, President & CEO
In the role
20 yr
Education
BS University of Michigan
Front Office rank
not ranked yet
ALL
The Allstate CorporationInsurance
Title
Chair, President & CEOsrc
In role
since 2007-01 (20 yr)
Stake value$236.0m1.0m shares · as of 1 Mar 2026
—thin record

Scouting sheetas of 24 Sep 2026

Delivers guidance—0 beat · 1 met · 0 missed · 1 withdrawn — fewer than 4, not scored
Answers the question—no call reviewed yet
Capital allocation100company five-year record: compounds
Pay design9093% performance-conditioned · roe, relative tsr, margin, revenue, operating income · 92.7% for · 0.22% of net income
Skin in the game75stake worth $236.0m, 10× last year's pay
50%Hit rate
93%Pay at risk
93%Say-on-pay
53%Airtime on calls
Beat
0
Met
1
Missed
0
Withdrawn
1
Still open
0
Answers on calls
0
Questions dodged
2
Dodges / 100 answers
—

Personal and ownership data

Full name
Thomas J. Wilson
Age
68src
Education
BS Business Administration, University of Michigansrc

Not on file yet: born, place of birth, citizenship, marital status.

Shares held
1,028,140 ALL, 2026-03-01src
Stake value
$236.0m
Stake ÷ pay
10× last year's pay
Traded, 12 months
bought $0, sold $41.6msrc
Last pay
$22.9m 2025src
Pay at risk
93%
Say-on-pay vote
92.7% forsrc
CEO pay ratio
306 : 1

What to weigh

Watch 6

  • Two analysts on the 2026-08-05 call asked where the auto combined ratio goes from a 12-point cushion. He redirected both times (dossier S8 dodge roll-up, turns 22 and 54)src
  • The 30% Performance Net Income part of the bonus pool paid at the 200% cap in 2025 ($8,634m against a $6,140m maximum). The measure replaces catastrophes with plan but keeps reserve releasessrc
  • Sold 201,684 shares for about $41.6m in the 12 months to 2026-09-24, all under a 10b5-1 plan adopted 2025-06-27, across 12 Form 4s from October 2025 to March 2026src
  • The CFO seat has had three occupants since October 2025: Merten, then Dugenske as interim, then outsider Christian Lown from 2026-08-03src
  • Say-on-pay support fell to 92.7% of votes cast at the May 2026 meeting, from over 95% in 2025; his own re-election drew 13.4m votes againstsrc
  • Combined Chair and CEO for 18 years, age 68 and retirement-eligible under the plans. Rizzo became COO in October 2025, but no successor has been namedsrc

In their favour 2

  • About 93% of 2025 CEO pay was at-risk; his equity is 70% PSAs on ROE and relative TSR and 30% options, with no time-vested RSUssrc
  • Owns 1.07% of the company counting exercisable options, the only insider above 1%. Company policy bans hedging and restricts pledging, and no shares were pledged at 2026-03-01src

Pay

Salary and otherBonus, stock, options, incentive

  • $16.5m2023
  • $26.7m2024
  • $22.9m2025
The table
YearSalaryBonusStockOptionsIncentiveOtherTotal
2023$1.4m$0$7.9m$5.0m$2.1m$156k$16.5msrc
2024$1.4m$0$11.9m$4.7m$8.0m$91k$26.7msrc
2025$1.5m$0$10.9m$4.5m$5.6m$442k$22.9msrc
Bonus pays on
Cash pool 70% business results (P-L profitable-growth matrix on combined ratio and policies in force, Protection Services premium and income, investment income and return) and 30% Performance Net Income; CEO target 300% of salary, 2025 funded 127%
Long-term award pays on
70% PSAs vesting on three-year average Performance Net Income ROE (60%) and relative TSR (40%), 30% stock options; target 1,024% of salarysrc
  • Pay at risk 93% performance-conditioned
  • Pays on returns roe, relative tsr, margin, revenue, operating income
  • Shareholder vote 92.7% for
  • Pay vs profit 0.22% of net income

CEO pay ratio 306 : 1

Career

  1. 2018 – now
    The Allstate Corporationsrc
    Chair, President & CEO
    President title resumed February 2018
  2. 2015 – 2018
    The Allstate Corporationsrc
    Chair & CEO
    Did not hold the President title from January 2015 to February 2018
  3. 2008 – 2015
    The Allstate Corporationsrc
    Chair, President & CEO
    Chair since May 2008
  4. 2007 – 2008
    The Allstate Corporationsrc
    President & CEO
    CEO since January 2007; President since June 2005; director since 2006
  5. 1995 – 2007
    The Allstate Corporationsrc
    Senior roles across the operating units, including CFO and Chairman & President of Allstate Financial
    The proxy says only that he 'held other senior executive roles and led all major operating units' and previously served as CFO; the years and titles come from the search result
  6. 1986 – 1993
    Dean Witter Reynoldssrc
    Managing Director, mergers and acquisitions
  7. 1980 – 1986
    Amocosrc
    Financial positions

Not located: 1993-1995 (Sears, Roebuck, which the 2012 State Street announcement names as a prior employer, and the move to Allstate) not dated in any source searched; the proxy's 32.8 years of combined Sears-Allstate service is the only primary figure for that period

The promise ledger2 scored · 0 open

ResultWhat was promisedWhere it is scoredHow
M MetThe $1.5bn share repurchase programme announced February 2025, to be completed in 2026ALL row 7said it, with a colleague
W WithdrawnThe long-standing 14–17% return-on-equity targetALL row 8said it

Questions dodgedno call reviewed

  1. Where the auto combined ratio goes from here — asked twice in one call, by two analysts, and redirected both times. Call 2026-08-05 [20] · Charles (Greg) Peters: "you're running substantially below your 10-year average combined ratio. And I'm reconciling Slide 9 where your flat rate change -- just curious about the competitive environment and when you might start to see that combined ratio drift up more toward…

    from ALL · dossier-2026-09-24.md

  2. Where the auto combined ratio goes from here — asked twice in one call, by two analysts, and redirected both times. Call 2026-08-05 [20] · Charles (Greg) Peters: "you're running substantially below your 10-year average combined ratio. And I'm reconciling Slide 9 where your flat rate change -- just curious about the competitive environment and when you might start to see that combined ratio drift up more toward…

    from ALL · dossier-2026-09-24.md

Calls reviewed

  • FY2026 Q2 call — 0 answers, 53% of the words

Background

  • Family The 2026 proxy reports no related-person transactions since the start of 2025; no Item 401(d) family-relationship statement was found in the proxy text searchedsrc
  • Boards Former director of State Street Corporation (elected October 2012); no other public-company board todaysrc
  • Boards Chairs the board's Executive Committee; an independent Lead Director (Richard T. Hume) sits alongside the combined Chair-CEOsrc
  • Service Chair of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce board of directors 2017-19; chair of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Foundationsrc
  • Giving 133,047 of his reported shares are owned by a private charitable foundation in which he shares voting and investment powersrc
  • Other Holds part of his stake through GRAT trusts and TJW Options LLC vehicles; in December 2025 he moved vested employee options into those LLCs (Form 4)src

Sources11